How Do You Invest During War? Market Strategists Weigh In
‘Nuclear war is a risk in my research’
A turbulent start to the week saw stock markets fall around the world, with the S&P 500 recording its sharpest daily decline since October 2020, while the Nasdaq and Germany’s benchmark index slipped into bear markets. Investors and analysts are assessing the latest developments in the war in Ukraine, revising their forecasts to take account of everything from commodity supply shortages (more on that below) to President Vladimir Putin of Russia putting his nuclear forces on alert.
Peter Berezin, a strategist at BCA Research, an investment advisory firm based in Montreal, made waves with a recent note about market positioning when, as he put it, the odds of a civilization-ending nuclear war in the coming year have risen to 10 percent. Despite the rising “risk of Armageddon,” he wrote, investors should “stay bullish on stocks.”
DealBook spoke with Berezin, who was an economist at Goldman Sachs before joining BCA, for more details on his eye-catching investment thesis. The conversation has been edited and condensed.
What has been the reaction to the report?
It has generally been positive. To the extent that there have been some negative reactions, they have generally stemmed either from a misunderstanding of my argument or from the feeling that the tone of the report was too alarmist.
People have said it was needlessly alarmist. But look at the pandemic. We should have been more alarmist. I am not trying to write something that is sensational. But I don’t think you should pull punches. I bought some potassium iodide. So on a personal level, if I am going to do that, then I shouldn’t ignore that nuclear war is a risk in my research. To not acknowledge it would be hypocritical.
So what were you trying to say, exactly?
What I wasn’t trying to say was that stocks were going to go up if there is a nuclear war. Obviously, they will go down. The point is that everything else will go down, too.
So, you have this odd asymmetric risk from an investment point of view. One scenario is that the conflict is contained and reaches some equilibrium. In that situation, stocks go up. If the threat doesn’t dissipate, well, you probably won’t be around to witness the aftermath. From a personal perspective, you should care about whether there is a nuclear war. But from a financial perspective, since you can’t hedge, the best advice is to position for a freakout and buy stocks when they are down.
But isn’t there a middle ground, in which we don’t have a nuclear war but the global economy still suffers?
Down the road, that’s the future that I envision. We are going to be moving to a world where the world is less globalized. And globalism is deflationary. So we are at an inflection point for bond yields and inflation, and going to move into inflationary environments.
If that’s the case, why would you be bullish on stocks?
What’s moving stocks now is the conflict and investors grappling with how this conflict will be resolved. Look at commodity prices. Markets are assuming that oil prices will come back down. That’s the right conclusion. Prices will revert.
HERE’S WHAT’S HAPPENING
Bed Bath & Beyond soars after an activist arrives. Shares in the retailer jumped 34 percent yesterday after Ryan Cohen, the co-founder of Chewy, unveiled a stake and pushed for changes in strategy. That led to more than $50 million in paper gains for Cohen, whose investment in GameStop helped stoke meme-stock mania.
The Biden administration proposes new auto pollution limits. The E.P.A. unveiled draft rules that would cap emissions of nitrogen dioxide and carbon dioxide for buses, delivery vans and heavy trucks, while the White House announced $5.5 billion in federal aid to help states buy low-emission transit buses.
Inflation expectations hit a high. The so-called 10-year break-even rate, which reflects bond investors’ prediction for inflation over the next decade, nearly reached 2.8 percent yesterday, a level unseen in almost three decades.
New York City schools drop their mask mandates. Students were allowed to go mask-free as Mayor Eric Adams took a big step to return the city to normal, though some students still felt uncomfortable doing so. In other pandemic news, Puerto Rico eased its mask mandate, while Florida said it would recommend against giving healthy children coronavirus vaccines.
Apple prepares to unveil new gadgets. The tech giant will host a product event today, which is largely expected to be centered around product upgrades. Expect a new iPad Air and a lower-priced iPhone SE, and potentially new laptops and desktop computers.
The latest on the Russia-Ukraine war
Congress is putting pressure on the Biden administration to ban Russian oil imports, as the U.S. and allies weigh tougher punishments for Moscow. But Chancellor Olaf Scholz of Germany said he was reluctant to impose a ban, given his country’s dependence on Russian fuel. And despite joining in financial sanctions against Russia, Switzerland remains a hub for the trading of Russia’s raw materials and resources.
More companies have suspended operations in Russia, including Levi Strauss and the venture capital firm Index Ventures. But the C.E.O. of Uniqlo’s parent company defended keeping its 50 stores in Russia open: “Clothing is a necessity of life.”
FIFA will let foreign players and coaches contracted by Russian teams break their agreements and play elsewhere.
The Russia-Ukraine War and the Global Economy
“There is a recognition that the idea of a competitive labor market is a fiction. This is a sea change in economics.”
— Ben Harris, an assistant Treasury secretary in the office of economic policy, on the Biden administration’s new report about the state of labor market competition. The recent narrative is that a tight labor market is giving workers leverage, but the report argues that the deck is still stacked against workers.
Heavy issues in metal markets
Extraordinary moves in the market for nickel, where prices rose by 70 percent yesterday and at one point doubled in early trading today, led the London Metal Exchange to halt trading in the commodity “on orderly market grounds.” Russia accounts for about a tenth of the world’s supply of nickel, particularly the variety used in electric vehicle batteries.
“Fear of shortages is triggering panic buying,” an analyst told Reuters. The effects that the war in Ukraine and sanctions against Russia are having on energy markets have grabbed the headlines, but reliance on other Russian commodities, like nickel, has put global supply chains under pressure. Many of these crucial minerals are used in electric cars, solar panels and other green-energy applications.
The world can’t afford to spurn Russian minerals, said Lewis Black, who heads Almonty Industries, a tungsten mining and exploration company based in Canada. Tungsten, which is increasingly in demand for tech products, is on the Biden administration’s newly updated “critical mineral list,” along with nickel, palladium, aluminum and others. Russia has the world’s second-largest reserves of tungsten, behind China. For some time, companies have relied on Russian mines in an effort to minimize dependence on China — and they now find themselves in a bind, Black told DealBook.
Cutting off direct purchases of Russian minerals won’t stop them coming via China, Black said: “Even though the material may not leave Russia in the traditional routes coming over the border into Europe, the consensus within the sector is that it will find its way still into Europe.” Russia is “one of the principal suppliers of raw materials globally,” Black said, so “it’s not a question of just saying, ‘We can’t buy it anymore.’ There’s nothing to replace it with.”
Diversifying the supply chain for critical minerals is a Biden administration priority. Last month, days before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the White House announced a series of investments designed to jump-start American mineral mining and address U.S. dependence on “foreign sources and adversarial nations.” But this isn’t a quick process, and despite high prices for the commodities it sells, the energy-intensive mining industry may not be able to ramp up production to meet demand because of soaring prices for oil and gas, further restricting supplies.
THE SPEED READ
Mobileye, Intel’s self-driving car division, filed to go public via I.P.O. (Bloomberg)
The tech sell-off has been brutal for the “Tiger Cub” group of hedge funds, like Tiger Global and Coatue. (FT)
Google agreed to buy the cybersecurity company Mandiant for $5.4 billion. (Google)
Bill Ackman’s Pershing Square has bought a new stake in the Canadian Pacific railroad, after exiting its first investment in the company in 2016. (Reuters)
The venture firm Griffin Gaming Partners has raised $750 million for its second fund. (Hollywood Reporter)
Disney’s C.E.O., Bob Chapek, defended not speaking up against a Florida bill that critics say discriminates against gay people, but said the company would “reassess” its political advocacy policies. (Hollywood Reporter)
U.S. business executives in China worry that Washington-Beijing relations have deteriorated to Trump-era levels, a new survey finds. (CNBC)
In crypto news: Senator Ron Wyden, the Democratic chair of the Senate Finance Committee, warned against cracking down too hard on cryptocurrencies, and President Biden is expected to sign an executive order to study new crypto regulations. (FT, Bloomberg)
Best of the rest
Better.com, the online mortgage lender that gained notoriety for laying off 9 percent of its employees via Zoom, reportedly plans to lay off half of its remaining workers. (TechCrunch)
Disney sees sports betting as crucial to ESPN’s future. (FT)
The media publisher Axios sees a big business in local news and writing in bullet points. (NYT)
We’d like your feedback! Please email thoughts and suggestions to email@example.com.